Your privacy is a PRIMARY consideration of AskDrSears.com. Your
e-mail address is used ONLY by AskDrSears.com for the purpose of
announcing news, events and special offers available only
AskDrSears.com registered users.
Baby Sling Closeout Special! Extended through May until sold out!
Buy a baby sling for a friend and get one free for yourself or get just one at 50% off.
Buy one get one free Discount code: freesling
Or 50% off your babysling Discount code: halfoff expires: 05/30/08
*Not valid in conjuction with any other offers.
Your privacy is a PRIMARY consideration of AskDrSears.com. Your
e-mail address is used ONLY by AskDrSears.com for the purpose of
announcing news, events and special offers available only
AskDrSears.com registered users.
Did you ever wonder why grains received top-billing (or would it be bottom-
billing?) in the USDA's food pyramid? Pure and simply, grains are great foods. Grains are also
the world's most plentiful food and enjoy first place in the diet of nearly every culture, except
perhaps fish-loving Eskimos.
What makes grains so good? Around two-thirds of the calories in grains come from complex
carbohydrates. This is right in line with current dietary recommendations that 60 to 65 percent of
daily calories should come from carbohydrates. Grains are also a rich source of protein. In most
cultures, except beef-eating Westerners, most of the protein in peoples' diets come from grains.
(In our culture, it's the cattle who get their protein from grains.) Yet, the body can't live on
grains alone. Most are not complete proteins, since they are missing one or more of the essential
amino acids, usually lysine. No problem. Who eats dry cereal anyway? Mixing grains with
dairy, legumes, or just about any other protein source completes the minimal amino acid
deficiency of some grains. Also, grains are great sources of: fiber, zinc, iron, folic acid,
minerals, and B-vitamins. And there's more great news about grains-they're naturally low in
fat.
Even before the grain-heavy new food pyramid was put out by the USDA, grains were becoming
the "in" food, and new names of new grains are cropping up all the time. While all grains are
nutritious, some are more nutritious than others.
Wonderful wheat. In American diets, wheat is the top grain. Not only is it the most plentiful -
the wheat belt stretches over the middle of the United States and we export as much as we
consume - it's one of the most versatile grains. What gives wheat its unique baking value is the
protein gluten, the elastic substance that sticks together, allowing bread to rise
and pasta to hold its shape during cooking.
Wheats are rated according to the "hardness" of the grain, which is determined by the amount of
gluten it contains. Harder wheat have more gluten, and therefore a higher protein-to-
carbohydrate ratio, so they are used in foods that need to retain their shape and have a firmer
texture, such as bread and pasta. Softer wheats, such as pastry flour, are used in pastries and pie
crusts. "All purpose" flour is a blend of hard and soft wheats. Here
are some wheat terms you may not be familiar with:
The wheat bran is the outer layer of the wheat kernel that covers the
seed inside. It is removed when wheat is refined into white flour. Bran is the part of the
wheat kernel that is highest in fiber, primarily the insoluble type, which has been shown to
lower the risk of colon cancer. Bran is also the part of the wheat plant that contains most of
the minerals and vitamins.
The wheat germ is the nutrient-dense embryo of the wheat plant,
which is power-packed with protein, minerals, iron, and contains most of what little fat there
is in the wheat plant. (This is why processors like to remove it from flour, as it shortens the
shelf life.) Wheat germ is often used as a dietary supplement because it is rich in iron, B-
vitamins, vitamin E, and the antioxidant selenium.
The endosperm is the largest part of the wheat kernel and the least nutrient-dense. Yet,
because by weight the endosperm is about 80 percent of the whole wheat kernel, it contains
the greatest amount of proteins and carbohydrates.
Cracked wheat starts with the whole kernel of hard varieties of wheat. The kernels are
cracked into small pieces and add a crunchy texture when added to bread or cereal. Or, you
can cook cracked wheat in water like rice.
Wheat berries are the whole kernels of wheat. They take longer to cook than the cracked
variety. When cooked they can be eaten like rice or added to bread dough.
Bulgur wheat is a form of cracked wheat. The whole wheat kernels
are cooked, dried, and cracked into a coarse grain that is usually used in cooked cereal, pilaf,
or a favorite Middle Eastern grain dish, tabbouleh.
NUTRITIP
Brown Bread
Brown bread is not always more nutritious than white.
In fact, the brown color is often just a marketing gimmick, just white bread
with coloring added (like a fake tan). To tell if a brown bread is really more
nutritious, read the label. If the first ingredient is "whole wheat," this is a
healthy food. If it says "bleached" or "enriched" flour, or just wheat flour, it
is just colored white bread. Some labels will say only "wheat flour," which
is 75 percent white and 25 percent whole wheat. Always check the label
rather than going by color.
Spelt is a high-quality European whole wheat.
Wheat grass means the wheatgerm has been allowed to grow, or
germinate. Whether or not sprouted wheatgerm is more nutritious than an unsprouted
wheatgerm is uncertain. During the sprouting process, much of the fat and carbohydrates in
the seed is used for growth. The sprout still contains a lot of protein and, possibly, an
increased amount of vitamins and minerals. The nutritional benefits depend upon eating a
large volume of the sprouts, since they are now mostly water rather than protein by weight.
NUTRITIP
Weigh Your Bread
As a general guide, the heavier the bread the more nutrition it contains. When
shopping, compare breads by holding a loaf in each hand. The loaf that
weighs more is more loaded with nutrients. Bread made with whole wheat
flour is naturally heavier, firmer, and more nutrient-dense than airy white
bread.
Stone-ground whole wheat is ground the old-fashioned way -
between rotating stones - so that the bran, germ, and endosperm remain together. Wheat
purists believe that stone-grinding produces a more nutritious flour than the conventional
high-speed roller-milling, which, they claim, may overheat the grain and cause deterioration
of the nutrients. Stone-ground flour usually needs to be refrigerated once opened, since the
oil released during grinding makes it spoil more quickly. It's best to store any kind of whole
grain flour in the refrigerator if you won't be using it up within a month or two. Depending
on the heat produced during milling, nutritionally, stone-ground and roller-milled flour
should be about the same.
In comparing bread ingredient labels, use the same judgment tip we mentioned in comparing
yogurt labels: the shorter the ingredient list, the better the bread. The most nutritious bread may
be made from only whole wheat flour, water, yeast, and salt, with possibly a touch of molasses
and honey, or the addition of other "whole" grains. The key-word on the bread label is "whole."
Be particularly careful of the most recent little white label lie called "wheat flour," which does
not mean the same as whole wheat. Wheat flour, which gives bread a light brown color and
therefore more health appeal, is 75 percent white flour and only 25 percent whole wheat. So it's
only 25 percent healthy bread instead of 100 percent. By looking at labels, you can group breads
into three categories:
Best breads are 100 percent whole wheat. Whole wheat flour is the first ingredient on the
label. Enriched flour does not appear in the ingredient list. If it doesn't say "whole wheat,"
it's not. Wheat flour, as listed on labels, officially should mean 75 percent white and 25
percent whole wheat, but it may not. All white bread is "wheat flour," so this term is
misleading, at best. A truthful label would state what percentage is whole wheat. If a label
says "wheat flour," assume it's not whole wheat.
Better breads list "whole wheat flour" as the main ingredient, but may include white flour,
too.
Downright junk breads list "bleached, enriched flour" first in the ingredient list. Leave
these on the shelf where they belong. If it doesn't say "whole" on the label, it's wrong for
your body.
Non-wheat flours. The term "flour" doesn't necessarily mean wheat. Flour, and
therefore bread, can be made from any grain. But since other flours don't contain gluten, most of
these appear in bread in combination with wheat flour. They may appear on their own in other
types of baked goods. Popular non-wheat flours are:
Buckwheat flour. Despite its name, buckwheat does not contain
the wheat (or gluten) protein and is therefore digestible by gluten-sensitive persons.
It's a popular pancake flour, combined with wheat.
Oat flour. Oat flour is more commonly used in cereals than in
bread. When used with whole wheat flour, it makes a moister whole-grain bread.
Rye flour. Rye is a high-protein, high-fiber grain of at least equal nutrition to wheat
flour and is often used for breads. Look on the label for "unbolted" rye if you want
a whole-grain rye flour.
Cornmeal. This is made from white or yellow corn. You'll find
it in breads, pancakes, and muffins. If there is an American bread, cornbread would
be it. It was a staple of early pioneer diets. Like other flours, cornmeal comes either
bolted ("degermed") or unbolted. Corn flour is finely ground cornmeal.
Soy flour. Defatted, ground soybeans make a flour high in protein. You can
substitute soy flour for a small amount of the wheat flour in recipes to boost the
protein content of the finished product.
Arrowroot flour. Unlike the protein-rich wheat, arrowroot is primarily starch. It
comes from the root of a tropical plant called the maranta. Because it is easy to
digest, it's a popular ingredient in starter cookies for infants and children.
No matter how you slice it, whole wheat bread is more nutritious than white because whole
wheat bread contains the following:
nearly one-third more protein
three to four times the amount of fiber
four times more zinc
more folic acid
more iron
more chromium (an important mineral which regulates sugar and fat metabolism,
especially important in hyperactive children)
Although whole wheat bread is reported to have the same glycemic index as white bread, because
of the extra nutrients the carbohydrates in whole wheat bread may have less of a roller-coaster
effect on blood sugar.
The nutritional content of bread is not affected by the bread's shape or presentation-whether its
rolls, bagels, or sliced bread. What matters most is the kind of flour in the bread. The main
nutritional difference is whether breads are made with whole wheat or white flour.
As with grains, ranking breads is very difficult. We have attempted to rate them according to the
following nutrients: protein, fiber, calcium, iron, zinc, folic acid, niacin, riboflavin, and vitamins
B-6 and E (assigning one point each), and factoring in nutrients per calorie. Using this point
system, the breads rank:
Next to wheat, oats are the most popular grain found in breads and cereal, such as granola and
muesli. While oats are nutritionally similar to whole wheat, the oat kernel has not been taken
apart like the unfortunate wheat, so oats are often nutritionally superior to some forms of wheat.
If you see the word "groat" applied to grains, don't think it's a misprint. "Groats" is the term given to the to the whole kernels of any grain in the raw state-before any
processing. The most nutritious and practical way to use oats is to purchase oatbran and
sprinkle it on cereal or add it to baking goods. One-third of a cup of oat bran provides the
following:
130 calories
7 grams of protein
6 grams of fiber
iron, zinc, vitamin E, and B-vitamins
The fiber in oat bran is a perfect compliment to that in wheat bran. The fiber in wheat bran is
primarily insoluble (the colon-cancer-preventing fiber), while the primary fiber in oatbran is the
soluble, cholesterol-lowering kind.
Rolled oats, the kind you use in oatmeal, are made by rolling and heating whole grain oats so
they cook more quickly. In bread, rolled oats appear as pale flecks and help give bread a chewy,
moist texture. Uncooked, rolled oats appear in cereals, like muesli and granola.
Barley is a popular grain in cereals and, because its easily digested, is used as an alternative to
rice in baby cereals. Yet, because barley does contain some gluten, it is a less intestinal-friendly
cereal for gluten-sensitive children and adults. Unfortunately, most Americans get most of their
barley in beer, since barley malt is a popular grain in beer-making. Most of the barley
commonly used in cereal or bread-making is "pearled," which means it has been refined to
remove the germs and the bran, much like the degrading of whole wheat to white. You'll find
barley in many soups. It can also be cooked and used in main dishes as a substitute for rice.
Despite it's name, buckwheat is neither a wheat nor a grain. Botanically a fruit, this favorite
pancake-ingredient got its name from the Dutch word bockweit. Buckwheat enjoys a few
nutritional perks over wheat: it is much higher in the amino acid lysine, somewhat higher in
vitamin E, and is much lower in gluten, an important difference to gluten-sensitive individuals.
Buckwheat does have some fiber, primarily of the soluble type, but it is less of a source of fiber
than wheat and many of the other grains. Buckwheat is the main ingredient in a rice-like Eastern
European dish called kasha that is often served as a kasha-pilaf. In pancake
batter, the combination of eggs and buckwheat make buckwheat pancakes a complete protein.
Botanically, amaranth is not really a grain, but it has the nutritional profile of one. It surpasses
whole wheat in calories, protein, iron, zinc, copper, and nearly all nutrients, and is the grain
highest in folic acid, calcium, and vitamin E. Also, like wheat, amaranth is rich in the amino acid
lysine. It even contains a bit of vitamin C. Even though this overlooked and underappreciated
food is expensive and found only in nutrition stores, it is a grain with a future. Amaranth can be
added to other grains, used as a thickener, garnish, popped like popcorn, or added to homemade
bread. Because it is one of the most nutrient-dense foods, we have placed it at the top of our
greatest grains list.
NUTRITIP
Show Me the Grain.
In nutritious whole wheat bread (and some cereals), you should be able to see
the brown flecks of wheat (or the white flecks of millet) in the bread, and the
grains often feel crunchy with each delicious bite. Plain wheat bread will have
an airy appearance and a spongy feel.
Like amaranth, quinoa (pronounced keen-wa) is botanically not a grain, yet it has the nutritional
profile of a grain and similar uses. It ranks along with amaranth as a "super grain." It is higher
than other grains in protein and iron, folic acid, and some B-vitamins. Yet, it is deficient in the
amino acids, tyrosine and cystine and lower than some grains in fiber. Even though quinoa is
expensive and found mainly in specialty nutrition stores, it is a nutritious addition to other grains,
mixed and served in pilaf, in a sauce, or cooked as a cereal similar to oatmeal with a firmer, more
gooey texture and a much more distinctive flavor.
A popular grain in Asian and Middle Eastern flatbreads, millet is lower than wheat in fiber, but a
rich source of B-vitamins and trace metals. Because it's gluten-free, it isn't used as the main
grain in leavened breads. It can be used in its raw state as a healthy addition to some wheat
breads, where it appears as crunchy, white beads, or cooked like rice.
Rice enjoys a popularity similar to wheat. In Asia, it's the main grain. It is much less nutrient
dense than wheat, being lower in protein, fiber, iron, folic acid, calcium, zinc, vitamin E, and B-
vitamins. Rice's claim to fame is that it contains the most carbohydrates, which makes rice a
popular energy food in many cultures. Because of its easy taste and digestibility, the rice-lover
can make up for rice's lower nutritional quality by eating more quantity. Rice is much more
palatable than some of the more nutritious grains that overpower the senses with their taste and
aroma. Also, rice is one of the more intestinal-friendly grains. Since it is low in fiber and gluten-
free, it is often the grain of choice for persons, especially infants, recovering from diarrheal
illnesses or who are gluten sensitive.
White rice. The processing that refines natural brown rice into the white stuff, removes many of
the nutrients, similar to what the milling factories do in disassembling wheat. Brown rice is much higher than white (even the enriched variety) in the following nutrients:
protein, fiber, zinc, folic acid, vitamin E, B-vitamins, and calcium. Brown rice has over fifteen
times the amount of vitamin E as white rice. As with so many food tradeoffs, white rice is more
popular than brown because it is blander and quicker to cook. White rice belongs in the same
nutritional category as white bread.
Brown rice. Brown rice is much higher than white (even the enriched variety) in the following
nutrients: protein, fiber, zinc, folic acid, vitamin E, B vitamins, and calcium. Brown rice has
over fifteen times the amount of vitamin E as white rice.
Wild rice. Botanically, not really a grain but rather a grass, wild rice is much
more nutritious than even brown rice, being much higher in protein, zinc, folic acid, and vitamin
E. Not only is wild rice much more nutritious than white and somewhat more nutritious than
brown, it has a texture and flavor that far surpasses any other form of rice, accounting for its
popularity in finer restaurants. Once considered a delicacy, it is now so widely available that for
the nutritionally-minded person it is really the healthiest form of rice. Wild rice has gotten an
unfair rap by being dubbed "too expensive." Not true. After cooking, it swells to 3 or 4 times its
initial volume, so a little wild rice goes a long way. One cup of dried wild rice becomes three or
four cups of rice on the plate, enough for six to eight servings.
Rice terms. Besides white, brown, and wild, there are other terms that you will see associated
with rice that have more to do with taste, appearance, and mode of preparation than with
nutritional differences.
Rice bran. Rice bran is nutritionally similar to oat and wheat brans, but contains more
calcium, iron, zinc, and folic acid. Like other brans, it is a rich source of fiber, some of
which is in the cholesterol-lowering soluble form. Since rice bran is higher in fat and less
palatable than some of the other brans, it spoils quickly and is not a popular addition to
foods, though it is often added to rice cakes, cereals, and sprinkled on other foods.
Long-grain, medium-grain, and short-grain obviously refers to the length of the rice
particle. The longer the grain, the more fluffy is the rice and the less it clumps together.
Long-grain rice is the most popular variety in the U.S. and makes up most of the domestic-
grown rice. Medium and short-grain rice is more popular in Asian cooking. One reason is
because the short-kernel size and the higher percentage of starch makes the kernels clump
together, so it is easier to eat with chopsticks.
Enriched rice means that the B-vitamins, niacin and thiamin, have been added, as well as
iron to make up for the nutrients lost when brown rice is refined into white. This is a bad
nutritional deal, since more good stuff was taken out than is put back in. Better to just eat
brown rice.
Rice cakes are made of puffed-up rice, which is mostly air and very low in nutrition. But
rice cakes are an alternative to bread as a vehicle for nutritious spreads, such as peanut butter
and fruit spreads. Rice cakes, made with either white or the more nutritious brown rice, are a
favorite melt-in-the-mouth starter food for infants and a good snacking food.
Converted or parboiled means the rice has been soaked and steamed before milling, which
prevents some of the nutrients in the grain from being completely lost in the refining.
Converted rice retains a bit more of the folic acid and B-vitamins, but otherwise is essentially
the same as white rice. This rice may actually take longer to cook than white rice, and it may
yield a fluffier grain.
Instant rice (available in white or brown) shortens the cooking time from 20-30 minutes to
five minutes. Yet, as happens so often with processed foods, you trade away some nutrition
for a gain in convenience. Compared with regularly cooked rice, the instant variety has a bit
less of the following nutrients (though the differences may be insignificant): selenium, zinc,
B-6, folic acid, and much of the amino acids. Instant rice also loses a bit of its texture.
Basmati rice is a nutty-flavored rice with a dry texture more like nuts than rice. It is used in
Indian cuisine, available as brown or white.
Rye flour contains twice as much fiber, iron, zinc, vitamin E, B-vitamins, and calcium as whole
wheat flour. The amino acid profile of rye flour is also better than whole wheat. Does that make
rye bread better for you than whole wheat? Not exactly, for two reasons. In its original form, or
dark variety, rye flour is much more nutritious than wheat. But by the time the rye is refined, the
"light rye" contains around half the nutrients of the original, dark rye. In addition, most
American rye bread is not 100 percent rye, but a mixture of rye flour and refined wheat flour.
So, by the time the factory turns rye into bread, the product that reaches the supermarket is either
similar to, or less nutritious than, a slice of whole wheat bread. A mixture of whole rye flour
(also called dark rye flour) and whole wheat flour would be a terrifically nutritious bread.
It's misleading, if not impossible, to rank grains. Their relative value depends on what nutrients
you are looking for. Is one nutrient more important than another? Is fiber more important than
protein? Maybe, if you're a senior citizen, but not if you're a child. Do you judge nutritional
value by nutrients per ounce, or nutrients per calorie? When you see any rating system for food,
take it with a grain of salt and remember that variety is an important key to healthy eating.
In spite of these difficulties, we decided to give it a try and rate the twelve most common grains
according to the following nutrients: protein, fiber, iron, zinc, folic acid, vitamin E, riboflavin,
niacin, thiamin, and calcium. If you assign one point for each of these nutrients, the ratings come
out as follows:
The grains highest in calcium, ranked in order are: amaranth, quinoa, oats, barley, rye, and
whole wheat. Gluten-free grains are: corn, rice, soy. (Buckwheat may contain a small amount of
gluten.) The top five grains for iron are: quinoa, amaranth, oats, enriched rice, millet and barley.
The top grains for zinc (an important immune-booster) are: wild rice, rye, amaranth, oats, and
quinoa. The top grains for folic acid are: millet, wild rice, rye, amaranth, and oats.
Even though nutritionally amaranth would rank as the greatest grain, overall the top grain in our
book is whole wheat. Even though other grains may have slightly more nutrients, wheat is a
whole lot more useful in a whole lot more foods. Whole wheat comes out as top grain.
AskDrSears.com is intended to help parents become better informed consumers
of health care. The information presented in this site gives general advice
on parenting and health care. Always consult your doctor for your individual
needs.